[Home]


Commander 112/114/115 Service Data


Tech News & Information

FAQ

Hangar

Books/Publications

Manuals

Service Data

STC info

Aftermarket

Marketplace

COG Shop

Product Reviews

Community

Commander Forum

Events

Fly-ins & Outs

Travel

Honorary Members

Member Galleries

Contact us

Join Now!

The Commander Owners Group reserves the right to accept or reject any submissions for any reasons. All submissions become the property of the Commander Owners Group. Listed material is informational only and proper licensed personnel should be consulted as appropriate concerning any parts or service needs.

This area is dedicated for servicing information and tips. For specific parts information and sources, see the Hangar section. Have some good service insights to share? Submit your write-up along with pictures here.

Engine and Fuel Management

Landing Gear / Hydraulics

Official 2007 COG Gear Troubleshooting Guide (requires Adobe PDF Reader)

Electrical

Interior

Airframe / Exterior

General

The Commander Owners Group reserves the right to accept or reject any submissions for any reasons. All submissions become the property of the Commander Owners Group. Listed material is informational only and proper licensed personnel should be consulted as appropriate concerning any parts or service needs.

Engine and Fuel Management

  • Air / oil separator, all model - submitted by Bob Tippens (112TC), additional photos by Bill Bailey (112)

M20 installed/mounted on motor mount, pilots side.
Pictures from Taz.
Data from Wag Aero Catalog.

Air Oil Separator
FAA/PMA'd M-20 Air/Oil Separator, Model 300

SKU: I-287-000
Price: $360.00
----------------------------------------------------------
FAA/PMA'd M-20 Air/Oil Separator, Model 300 The Model 300 Separator is the only one of its kind to be Stc'd for all aircraft engines up to 315 hp. The Model 300 series is now 5 STC'd for engine sizes up to 315 hp and is also appropriate for Experimentals. No mounting brackets are needed. It mounts in the breather line with simple clamps. For use with dry vacuum pumps only. Both Code 4

SKU/Item#: I-287-000
Price: $360.00

A reeeeeeeeeally clean belly.
Oil loss/consumption improved/stopped from 3.5 flying hours per quart to 7. Always keep 7 on the stick.

top

  • Cable assemblies, various.

Beechhurst Industries (150-35 12th Ave, Whitestone, NY 11357. 718-746-3900). They can make up most of the cable assemblies used in the Commander. Send them the old cable and they'll use it as a guide to make up a new.

  • Electric Fuel Pump LED Indicator, all - submitted by Sven Faret

Ever leave the fuel pump on? We all have! I HATE when that happens, especially when you consider $1000 for a new one.

This LED blinks at you until you shut it off. I never leave it on more than necessary any more. I have FAA approval for the install with schematic & parts list for anyone interested.

top

  • Fuel leak from fuselage vent/drain, 114 models - submitted by Sam Butler

If you notice a flow fuel drip from below the fuel selector and fuel position handle position has no effect, the problem may be the vent in the tank. This is designed to be an emergency vent for fuel injected aircraft (keeps the wing from collapsing) and has no connection to the selector valve. There is a very simple check valve at the top of the tank (a ball and socket type). Very difficult to replace. You can determine which is leaking by only filling one tank. It will continue to drip until the fuel get below the valve. Solution, fill to the tabs unless going on a trip.

top

  • Fuel leak from wing seals, how to find. All models - submitted by Sam Butler (8/06)

As the owner of three commanders, I have become an expert in sealing the tanks. If your leak is near or along the area of the fuel pickup line, it will show itself at the access panel near the jack point. Also you will see some blue in the wheel well.
Take this plate off (it is an inspection plate not sealed) and clean this area and the fuel lines good with soap and water. After it is dry, use baby power to coat the area. use lots of powder.

Put the fuel selector value in both and jack up the other side of the plane. Keep checking on the powder as the tank fills. Use a mirror and You should see your leak.

You can do this several time by moving the jack from side to side.

top

  • Fuel selector, rebuild and o-rings and high to low wing transfer problem  - submitted by Brad McNamara

My fuel selector had a small blue stain on it during the annual inspection. I removed it, cleaned it, and tore it apart. The "O" rings were crusty-hard. CAC was unavailable, but the manufacturer of the part is Airight, Inc., in Wichita, KS (see contact info in Hangar). "everything is proprietary design data so he can't tell me the part numbers, but I could send them the unit and they would be happy to replace the "O" rings for me for $125.00".

Anyway, there are four "O" rings in the unit. After mic'ing out the parts, and performing test fits of various sized "O" rings, it appears the three internal "O" rings are MS29513-014 (two around the brass inserts, and one around the selector shaft), and the large static "O" ring seal is a MS29513-039. As it happens, the -039 is a bugger to find. Actually, I couldn't find it, but the one I removed is still in very good condition. The others are easy to find.

One thing I did discover, my plane has always had a fuel transfer problem, in that, whether the fuel selector was in "Off", or not, fuel would always make its way to the lower height tank. The two "O" rings around the brass inserts were so hard and shrunk that the brass inserts just fell out of the base unit. Fuel was able to still transfer around the "O" rings because of this even though it was in the "Off" position. So, if you have this same problem, it could be your selector valve.

top

  • Governor overhaul, 112 - submitted by Steve Posner (9/06)

If you are told your Edo-Aire 34-828-014-2 governor can't be overhauled, try Southwest Aero, Inc in Tukwila, WA (206)575-8732. They had the parts required and overhauled mine.

top
 

  • Hot cylinder cure, 114 (but relevant to all models) - submitted by Scott Sedam

Hallelujah!!!!! No more hot cylinder! from 410-430, now running 275-380. Amazing.

My mechanic's supposedly "lesser partner" took everything I gave him, and meticulously worked through everything, One-by one eliminating everything. The fuel flows were all good, compression good (to check for valve?), he had previously done all the probe, lead and injector swapping.

The mag timing was a bit off. But he said that taking the Mike Bush advise to heart and meticulously checking the seal of the baffles with lower cowl off, top on (sort of) and using flashlights and mirrors, revealed many small gaps you would not have thought were there. He said that he is going to give that article to several A & P friends. By the way, all of Mike Bush's old columns are on AvWeb for free. If you don't read them, you are missing some great stuff.

Bottom line is that even with a 200-hour engine and beautiful looking baffling, there were still issues that you could not detect with the cowl on. All my temps are now very level from 365 to 385 CHT and EGT's all look fine. The only anomaly is that #1 is now running way cool, about 340 CHT. He might open that one up a bit.

Here is the URL for the Mike Bush article on Cooling. http://www.avweb.com/news/columns/188945-1.html

top

  • Magneto - D3000 set screw info - submitted by John Potter

Heads up. Anytime you have a mechanic go into the dual magneto and try to move that set screw once it was done by a shop, you might encounter what I did. In Mexico I was stuck and a mechanic did that without knowledge of the peculiar nature of the D3000. He set it but it turned out 20 hours later it moved enough that I was stuck again. Another mechanic got it set again, and again without really knowing what he was dealing with, he'd never seen a D3000 before. To cut to the chase, I got back and in March 07 at annual ordered a rebuilt D3000 (yes, done by Kelly Aerospace). My mechanic went in and adjusted that screw, not really knowing the strange nature of the marks being used to set the points correctly. I saw him do it and scratched my head of why would he do it given that it was a factory rebuilt unit and really should not need any adjusting, but said nothing. Well---after 9 months of concern of having to clean plugs every 20-30 hours, even buying the fine-wires, and doing compression checks, injector cleaning, harness checks, etc., I finally had a hunch and sent the magneto to the repair shop. Sure enough, that set screw had the points way off. Not only that, it had not been torqued correctly. And this was after the plugs fouling on both mags, extreme roughness, etc. I did a little research and found out through an old AOPA article (Pilot Advisory, Bendix Dual Magnetos, 11/84) that that little set screw coming loose had caused 7 aircraft crashes -'78-'81 with engines suddenly stopping. Obviously that got my attention, operating over all sorts of terrain in the Sierras and over the Sea of Cortez without sight of land. My advice, ask questions if any casual mechanic wants to screw around with that set screw, and even if he knows about the unique character of setting the points using different markings than normal, make sure that "locktight" is used along with the correct torque. The factory rebuilt has a white paint that will tell you if anyone has disturbed that screw.

top
 

  • Master Relay testing, all models - submitted by Bill Bailey

It is possible that your relay is OK and your master switch internal contacts are grubby. Either circumstance can create the symptom you are describing. If you have time and are inclined:

  1. Shorting the appropriate coil contact to ground repeatedly (particularly the first try of the day after the plane has been sitting) and checking for the solenoid "slap" will help verify the relay coil is firing.
  2. Checking the resistance across the relay power contacts. Relay cable terminals work fine for this test... clip your meter leads to the terminals w/ the cable leading to the buss disconnected and watch the resistance values across the terminals while repeatedly activating the coil. It the power contacts are burned or dirty, the resistance may vary widely. A difference of more than 0.1 - 0.2 Ohms indicates a junk relay. (And the absolute value should be much less than 0.2 Ohms. Any significant resistance across the power contacts will absolutely squash the amount of power available to the ship's buss. Just 0.2 Ohms resistance in a 12V system will cut the available power by by nearly 50%.) Note: you should use a quality digital meter for checking the resistance values.
  3. Check the resistance across the master switch contacts as in # 2. Allowing the coil to reach ground (the switch's function in life) isn't as fussy or critical as allowing power to reach the aircraft buss, however, if the switch contacts are gummed up w/ carbon, dirt and grime, there may not be a good enough ground to permit the coil to reliably fire when you rock the switch shut. Check several closures.
    Barring a broken wire or funky ring terminal connection, you should find the culprit w/ the checks above. Don't rule out loose or marginal terminal connections either. Much of the wiring in these planes is well past it's prime and loose or broken connections cause many, many problems. Look at all the alternator & gear problems on the Board that end up being wiring issues.

A final thought is that given the cost of $13 - $30 for a relay, why not change it every three to five years when you change your battery? It's a key part of the aircraft electrical system critical path analysis. Think about what we spend changing pneumatic system filter elements each year or the ELT battery change every two years. Pretty cheap insurance.

Link to Part Number info

top
 

  • Oil change tip, 112 models

How do you get the filter off without getting a mess of oil on the back side of the engine?

Some users have found a solution using a small plastic funnel, a rubber band and a length of plastic tubing. Just poke a hole in the side of the filter near the rear edge and just high enough that a quarter turn will put the hole at the bottom. Turn the filter so the hole is at the bottom while holding the funnel (tubing connected and leading to the drain pan) under the filter. Temporarily secure the funnel to the filter with a large rubber band and wait an hour or more for the thing to drain. After that, a paper towel will easily clean up the couple of drops that escape.

top

  • Radio noise whine

Whine change pitch along with the engine RPM? If it does (among other possible causes) it could be caused by one bad diode in the multi-diode bridge rectifier in the alternator. You might not notice any degradation in battery charging...the chief symptom would be a sudden appearance of this whine in the radios that no amount of filtering or grounding will cure. (The cure would be to replace the diode).

top

  • Remote oil filter installation, 112 models - submitted by Bob Tippens

ADC Remote Oil Filter Installation on the Motor Mount rather than Fire Wall. Pictures from Taz. Installed for over a year and makes for a very clean remove/install process. Data from Wag Aero Catalog.

Remote Spin-On Filter for All Lycoming 0-320 & up by ADC

SKU: I-963-003
Price: $475.00
-----------------------------------------------------------
FAA/PMA'd. Lycoming 0-320 series & up w/standard screen housing. Adapter kit has a larger mounting bracket which allows the weight to be distributed more evenly on firewall. When removing tight spin-ons the anti-torque feature allows removal without damaging the firewall. Uses Champion CH48108 or CH48109 filters. Kit includes STC, hardware, hoses, fittings, engine adapter and installation instructions. Please specify aircraft make, model, serial number and "N" number. Shipped FOB factory. Code 4

SKU/Item#: I-963-003
Price: $475.00


 

top

  • Skytec lightweight starter installation, 112 models - submitted by Dave Kalbach (12/06)

Definitely spins the prop faster and makes hot starts a breeze.

SKU:
Price: Approx $400

Old starter - lead gets removed

Bracket comes off

Mounting bolts

Starter solenoid

On firewall here but location may vary depending on your serial number

Old and new

Note that new starter requires slightly more lead length

Mounting pad with starter off

A good time to clean up that area if needed

Washers

The starter ships with new washers. FAA mandates that these star washers can not be used twice.

New starter on

Leads reattached

Note regarding the Bogert large gauge cables;  I had heard of something referenced as starter drag. After replacing my starter I learned what it was. The new starter uses a solenoid instead of a throw out bearing to engage the bendix. I believe this combination causes excessive draw on initial start up. The result is the starter turns the prop one half rotation and stops. A simple off and on again with the key and it fires right up (the bendix is already engaged.) The Bogert cables are much larger (2 gauge) and have very little amperage loss over distance. This gives you more starting power and should alleviate the problem.

top

Landing Gear / Hydraulics

  • Nose gear collapse due to bent nose pin - submitted by Robin Miley

Check the pivot (through the engine mount) tube on the upper drag brace to see if it is hollow. The updated tube is solid. (both are stainless steel) The hollow tubes would deform and not let the link lock "over center". In most situations the indication would be on the nose gear--(down and locked) but the gear will still fold. The only way to tell if the hollow tube is at fault is to roll it on a true surface and see if it wobbles. This picture shows the replaced part (the ends are counterbored about 3/4"). See the parts information in the Hangar section.

top

  • Brake pressure temporary loss, all models - submitted by Bob Tippens (1/06)

Problem - upon landing little brake effectiveness. Pumping up brakes usually restores normal operation until next flight when symptoms repeat.

The main gear brake calipers are being compressed during main gear retraction because the brake caliper "bleed screw" makes contact with wing walk support in main gear wheel well causing the caliper to be compressed resulting in little to no toe brake stopping effectiveness upon landing. After pumping the brakes upon landing the brakes remain effective/pumped up until the next take-off and main gear retraction at which time the same sequence of events occur. The evidence of this occurrence came be seen inside the wheel well where the brake bleed screw leaves marks close to the edge of the wing walk support in one or both of the wheel wells. The bleed screw contact point on the support is close to the installed elevated square bumper pad that is aligned with the round rubber stopper installed on the back side of the main gears.

Given that all brake components have been serviced and are working as designed, the attached 337 and Commander DER documentation and drawing represent a fix for the described problem. A "Slot" must be created in the wing walk support within each main gear wheel well which will create a pass through space for each brake bleed screw rather than it making contact with the support followed by compression of the brake calipers.

top

  • Troubleshooting emergency gear extension issues, all models - submitted by Sven Faret (2/07)

Before you have your mechanic start ripping everything apart, here are some tips on how the system works and how to test operation

  • Remember to slow the aircraft to 90 knots or less. The on-coming air will keep the nose gear from extending at higher speeds
  • Pull the throttle back to idle. Even at 80 or 90 kts, the prop wash will make it difficult for the nose gear to drop. At idle you can also better hear the positive gear down 'thunk' made by the system

top

  • Gear pump operating indicator, 114 all models - submitted by Julian Dinsdale (12/05)

There has been a lot of discussion over the years relating to the Hydraulic Gear Pump and whether or not there should be some additional indicators on the instrument panel. I have had some weird problems over the past 5 years which would have been easier to sort out if I had some additional info when they occurred. I decided to go through the hoops here in Australia to put some indicators on the panel which indicate if the Hyd Gear motor is running "up" or "down". The indicator lamps are from Aircraft Spruce and are similar to those already installed on the panel. Below are links to the EO plus my notes I sent to the aero-engineer. They may help others who are considering additional indicators.

Engineering Order, Schematic, Engineering Order Request

top
 

  • Nose gear pin drawing - submitted by Frank Sapienza (5/05)

Nose Gear Pin Technical Drawing (PDF format)

top

  • Landing gear bounce on extension, 112 earlier models - submitted by Gord Tessier

Issue: On gear extension, the gear extends normally except when it arrives at the very end of its cycle. The pump then cycles on and off rapidly, and ground tests indicate a "hydraulic bounce," or slight reversal of the pump or fluid flow, which is causing the lock pin on the nose gear cylinder to slightly retract away from the full engaged position. When this occurs, the microswitch thinks the gear isn't fully down and repeats the cycle several times a second.

"This happened to one of the Canadian 112's coming into CYSN one day. The problem was as you stated ..up pressure in the down cycle which caused the nose gear to collapse on landing as it was not over center. The culprit was in fact the check valve in the gear pump. sorry, but it's time for a new pump.

top

  • Troubleshooting and gear down relay replacement write-up, 114A - submitted by John Uhl

Click here

top

  • Troubleshooting intermittent running hydraulic gear pump, all models, submitted by Robin Miley (12/06)

If you experience intermittent gear pump operation, it can be caused by either failures of o-rings, a problem with the hydraulic pack itself, or air trapped in the system somewhere. When you get the airplane on the jacks, before you open any fittings or remove any actuators etc..., put the emergency down knob in the Emergency Down position (down) and then turn the master on and let the pump run for 20 or 30 seconds. This will flush all of the air from the "up hydraulic lock".

As the pump is still running, place the Emergency Down knob the the normal up position and let the gear come up and shut off.
Turn the master switch off. Leave the airplane on the jacks, with the gear up, for an hour or so and then turn the master on again and see how long the pump runs to pressure up the system and shut off. It should only take 1-3 seconds to re-pressurize and shut off. All of the wheels should remain up or very close to full up.

If it's much longer than that, (say 10-20 seconds) you then can look for the leaking actuator. Also, if one of the wheels starts to immediately fall from the up position (master off) that is likely the leaking actuator.


top

Electrical

  • Strobe Power Supplies, eliminating noise - submitted by Neal Dilman

You can get rid of strobe noise by using a "ferrite choke" on the + going to each strobe power supply. Alternatively, you can use "the eliminator" (Lonestar Aviation) or a similar product for the same purpose. Unless its the strobe light itself...

and from Jeffrey A Boccaccio

As 08J goes back together with a re finished panel I am trying to take care of all the little irritants that bother me. One in particular is the cross modulation I was getting from my strobes.

I found the problem that I am sure other Commanders also have. The noise is being developed from a relatively high resistance on the supply cable supplying the buss for all the switches from strobe to landing lights and master radio. This large cable is screwed into the buss with a #8 Philip's head. Under normal conditions this would work OK, however, because the cable is so long and heavy its mass just moves the cable by movement. Very easy to test when you get to it. Just hold it and move it a little bit. The eyelet should not rotate. It was this connection that cause the noise. I replaced this screw with a self-locking #8 3/8's socket. Now you can get in there and really torque it up to a solid lock. Completely stopped all the noise and whatever else it might have been causing. Easy to see if you remove whatever you have in the bottom tray of your stack.

top

Interior

  • How to remove front seats - submitted by Sven Faret

Tie wrap the seat lock handle fully opened or the locking pins will cause you grief. Remove the 2 rear seat rail stop pins. Also slide the seat rear wards to get the pin lock supports aligned with the seat rail notches, lift up the rear and out it comes. (sort of)

Now the hard part. The seat rollers are full of grease, the carpet and door trim will get in the way and beat up, the consol will be in the way too. Best is to put a wide piece of aluminum between the rollers and the carpet. If the carpet was cut too tight to the track end then roller tangle will occur.

Now that you have paid some one 1/2+ hour to ruin several interior items it's ready for them to smash the hump under the seat.

It seems that all commanders have the fuel line cover (under the seat) destroyed by some radio man at some point having the small of his back resting on it. It was never meant to hold 200 lbs of man with his legs up in the air trying to get out. Make a shelf for him to sit and work on to save the plane from hidden damage.

If you care for your plane don't discount any of this.

top
 

  • Plastic and fiberglass repair (interior and exterior)
    •  Fusor 101EZ - submitted by Peter Barratt

I also had to perform some repairs to the plastics (wingtips and fairings) as they had been damaged/split/cracked either through age or hangar rash. Initially I was going to use epoxy/glassfibre cloth reinforced with carbon fibre tows to effect the repair but was put onto a fantastic product by an auto body/spray shop.

I am so impressed by the product that I thought I should let the group know about it. Its called 'fusor 101EZ' (see www.fusor.com) and provides an easy to work with structural repair to plastics, fibreglass etc. The result is considerably stronger than had I used epoxy/glass cloth with a bit of carbon fibre in it, was easy to provide a buildup and is easy to sand once cured (24 hrs at room temp or 10-20 minutes with heat gun). It is also relatively flexible so seems to be an ideal solution for this (and other plastics) types of repair.

Aside from the ease of use, there is the fear factor of its actual use - the packaging reads like a law suit waiting to happen!!
 

  • Urethane Supply Company - submitted by Glenn Mores

This shop has anything needed for professional plastic repair. The site includes a great tutorial with pictures showing a complete repair of a badly cracked and broken plastic panel overlay for an aircraft. http://www.urethanesupply.com/

top
 

Airframe / Exterior

  • 112 cowl flaps, correcting deformation - submitted by Sven Faret

Original cowl flap doors

I've seen dozens of Commanders with cowl flpa doors that look like this. It's rare to see a plane in this situation without severe cracking and repairs around the cowl flap hinge area.

New look

They should look like this

Bracket

The problem comes from distortion of the cowling during flight. I'm sure many pilots wonder why they can't retract the cowl flaps 100% after the get the airspeed over 80 kts. Only to find that the instrument panel wants to deflect before the cowl flap control is fully closed. The wear point in the upper picture is where it stops.

Bracket Support

These photos show a simple bracket & support that allows full swing of the cowl flaps during any speed, keeps the paint from scuffing, cowling from cracking & smooth cowl flap operation.

 

Front view

top

  • Paint stripper for plastic and fiberglass parts - submitted by Peter Barratt

An update on what I have found works (really well) for the removal of two pack paint from the plastics for wingtip, elevator and rudder/tail tips. I was initially very concerned that the usual plethora of strippers would damage the plastics (especially after reading the "what not to use it on" caveats from the manufacturers), most seemed too harsh or strong so my obvious concern was damage to the plastics.

I found a very slow acting stripper called CITRISTRIP (http://www.citristrip.com/) that applied as a thick gel. As a slow acting stripper it took about 2 hours to soften the epoxy paint to a point where I could gently remove it with a flexible putty knife. Once the wingtips were clean of paint I thoroughly washed the part down (hot soapy water) to ensure that no residues were left on the plastics. All in all, approx 1 hour per wingtip plus time waiting for stripper to take effect.

top

  • Rudder spar missing rivets - submitted by Ron Bishop

Apparently the factory may have missed some important rivets in the tail assembly on a very few planes. This write-up has good pictures and service information. Definitely worth checking at the next annual. Click here.

top

  • Tail tutorial: disassembly and internal pictures - submitted by Sven Faret

 

 

General
  • Preventative Maintenance tips, aft - submitted by Bill Bailey (12/06)

If you have some of the interior removed for service or another purpose, here are some tips for some preventative maintenance items you can take a look at.

Power pack is pretty straight forward. There is a slotted round head screw w/ small o-ring on a step-down boss on the left side nearest you as you look at the unit from the baggage compartment access panel. (or to be a little more technically accurate... the inboard forward corner of the pump reservoir) This screw covers the reservoir filler port. Remove the screw to check (don't drop it as it could roll forward and become a PIA to retrieve if your interior is installed) the fluid level. Should be full to the top. If not, add H-5606 to fill to brim. Tighten screw just to seal o-ring under screw... not rip it in two.

NOTE: there is a second screw above the filler w/ a larger flat rubber ring underneath, this is the reservior vent and you do NOT want it cranked down. Has to allow air to enter as the fluid is used from the reservoir. Finger tight and back off just enough to insure vent can breathe. Instructions available in Maintenance manual.

Check your logs to see when your main and gear solenoids/contactors were last replaced. These are not expensive (well under $20 each). If the main power contactor has been installed for more than 5 years, consider replacing it before it becomes unreliable. Cheap PM. Gear contactors don't get as much use and have longer useful lives, but if they are still OEM from original manufacture, it's definitely time to replace for PM purposes. If you have original clamping diodes installed across the contactor coils, these cost pennies to replace and be certain to install them w/ the same polarity as the old ones. These do not need frequent replacement. If they are missing, go get some and make it right straight away. Info in hangar section for all these parts.

Good time to lube the exposed control cable pulleys. Check the battery terminals and box for corrosion. If using a flooded cell battery, check the electrolyte levels.

If your ELT batteries are coming due for replacement in the near future, you may want to go ahead and change them while you have the back end open. Good time to complete "tested ELT I/A/W FAR 91.207(d). No discrepancies noted. Next chg due xx/xx/xxxx"

Visually inspect overhead structure (vertical stabilizer) for cracks, etc.

All kinds of interesting stuff to look at back there. Crawl in and check it out. Have fun!

 


Questions or problems regarding this Web site should be directed to the webmaster
Copyright © 2003 Commander Owners Group. All rights reserved.